Governance reviews

We developed our Governance Review to help Trustees and key staff improve the effectiveness of their governance and to ensure that they are compliant with current regulations in all aspects of their organisation’s activities. The review covers:

  • The Legal Framework: are your documents in order; do you operate in accordance with your own governing documents?
  • The Board: do the Trustees have the required skills and experience?
  • Organisation and Advisers: are the responsibilities and reporting methods clear, effective and relevant?
  • Policies and Procedures: are these recorded and do they meet the requirements of current legislation?
  • Grantmaking: is your programme monitored, controlled and secure?
  • Finance: can you demonstrate that your controls are effective?
  • Strategy: do you have an effective strategy?

Frequently asked questions

When should trustees review strategy and governance practice?

Trustees should review strategy and governance when the foundation’s circumstances, leadership, activities or external environment change, and periodically even when no immediate problem exists. The Trust Partnership can support structured reflection on trustee responsibilities, meetings, policies, regulatory submissions and the practical arrangements that turn board decisions into action.

Read the full answer

A review is timely when the strategy no longer guides decisions, trustees are unclear about priorities or responsibilities, policies have become outdated, or the foundation’s scale and activities have changed. Regular review can also identify improvements before a concern becomes a governance failure.

The Trust Partnership supports trustees with agendas, board packs, minutes and follow-up, as well as governance and compliance guidance, regulatory submissions, policies and procedures. This operational perspective helps connect governance expectations with the foundation’s day-to-day arrangements.

The review should end with a prioritised action plan, named owners and dates for reconsideration through the normal board cycle. Trustees should record why changes are needed and how the board will know whether governance practice has improved.

Are our governing documents still fit for purpose?

Governing documents are fit for purpose when they still support the foundation’s charitable objects, current structure and practical decision-making. If provisions are unclear, outdated or restrict how trustees need to operate, The Trust Partnership can help frame the governance questions and coordinate appropriate specialist advice where a legal change may be required.

Read the full answer

Trustees should compare the governing document with the foundation’s current activities, trustee composition, meeting arrangements, powers and decision-making practice. Recurring workarounds or uncertainty about authority can indicate that the document no longer supports the organisation effectively.

The Trust Partnership can help trustees assemble the relevant information, review associated policies and procedures, and identify the operational effects of any issue. The Trust Partnership can also help distinguish matters that can be addressed through clearer practice from those requiring specialist legal advice.

Any proposed change should be considered against charitable purpose, regulatory requirements and implementation needs. The board should document its rationale and ensure that related policies, records and procedures are updated consistently after a decision.

How should a board approach self-assessment?

A board should approach self-assessment as a constructive review of collective effectiveness rather than an exercise in scoring individuals. The assessment should consider skills, role clarity, information, meetings, decision-making, policies and follow-through, with The Trust Partnership helping to structure the process and turn findings into practical actions.

Read the full answer

The board should begin by agreeing the purpose and scope of the assessment. Questions should focus on whether trustees collectively have the knowledge and information needed, understand their responsibilities, use meeting time well and maintain appropriate oversight.

The Trust Partnership can support the process by reviewing meeting arrangements, induction, board papers, policies, responsibilities and the administration of actions. Evidence from current practice can make the discussion more specific and reduce the risk of producing only general observations.

The outcome should be a small number of agreed improvements with clear ownership. The board can revisit those actions at an appropriate point in its annual cycle and use the exercise to strengthen governance continuously rather than wait for an external challenge.

Do we have the right skills, knowledge and experience around the board?

A board has the right mix when trustees collectively understand the foundation’s purpose, grant-making, finances, governance and key risks, and can challenge and decide effectively. The Trust Partnership can help structure a skills review and identify whether gaps are best addressed through induction, development, professional support or recruitment.

Read the full answer

The assessment should begin with the foundation’s current strategy and expected decisions rather than a generic list of desirable skills. Trustees should consider collective capability, diversity of perspective, succession and the ability to obtain specialist input when necessary.

The Trust Partnership can support a structured board discussion and review trustee responsibilities, induction, meeting information and governance arrangements. Better papers, clearer roles or targeted development may address a perceived gap without immediately changing board membership.

Where a continuing gap affects oversight or strategic decisions, trustees can define the expertise and capacity required before recruiting. The board should revisit the skills picture as priorities and membership change.

When does a skills gap become a recruitment need?

A skills gap becomes a recruitment need when it is important to the foundation’s continuing oversight or future direction and cannot be addressed adequately through training, clearer roles, better information or external advice. The Trust Partnership can help trustees diagnose the gap before deciding whether recruitment is the right response.

Read the full answer

Boards should first identify the decisions or responsibilities that are not being supported effectively. A perceived skills problem may arise from weak induction, unclear expectations, unsuitable papers or limited access to specialist advice rather than the absence of another trustee.

The Trust Partnership can review governance arrangements, trustee support, meeting information and development needs. If these changes will not provide sufficient continuing capability or capacity, the board can define a recruitment brief based on evidence.

Recruitment should be linked to strategy, succession and the collective composition of the board. Trustees should record why a new appointment is necessary and how the board will integrate and support the incoming trustee.

Are our structure and governance still right for our purpose?

Structure and governance remain right for purpose when they enable trustees to fulfil the foundation’s objects, make timely decisions and oversee resources effectively. The Trust Partnership can help examine how current arrangements work in practice and identify questions that require governance improvement or specialist legal advice.

Read the full answer

Trustees should consider whether the legal structure, governing document, board composition, delegations and meeting arrangements support the foundation’s present activities and future plans. Workarounds, recurring uncertainty or disproportionate administration may indicate misalignment.

The Trust Partnership can organise a structured review of governance and operating arrangements, bringing together documents, policies, decisions and practical experience. This helps separate issues that can be addressed through clearer processes from those involving structural change.

If legal or constitutional changes are being considered, trustees should obtain appropriate specialist advice before committing. Any agreed change should be accompanied by an implementation plan covering governance records, policies, systems and responsibilities.

What could we improve even if nothing is wrong?

Even when operations are satisfactory, a foundation can improve the alignment of governance, grant-making, administration and reporting with its purpose and stakeholder needs. The Trust Partnership can facilitate a structured review and help trustees prioritise practical improvements rather than wait for a problem.

Read the full answer

Continuous improvement begins with reflection on what is working, where effort is disproportionate and whether current practices still serve the foundation’s mission. Trustees can consider board information, applicant experience, decision processes, monitoring and operational resilience.

The Trust Partnership can review governance, grant management, administration and financial processes and help convert broad ambitions into defined actions. Its shared-resource approach allows support to be matched to the foundation’s priorities and budget.

The board should select a small number of improvements with clear ownership and measures. A staged approach protects continuity and makes it easier to learn from each change before moving to the next.

What does stronger foundation practice look like?

Stronger foundation practice combines clear purpose, effective governance, proportionate funding processes, reliable administration and continuous learning. The Trust Partnership can help trustees assess these connected areas and implement improvements suited to the foundation’s scale and priorities.

Read the full answer

Strong practice is visible in decisions that follow charitable objects and strategy, trustees who understand their responsibilities, and processes that give assurance without unnecessary complexity. It also considers the experience of applicants, grantees and other stakeholders.

The Trust Partnership can support trustee meetings and governance, grant assessment and management, administration, records and coordinated financial support. This provides a practical view of how separate parts of the foundation work together.

Improvement should be evidence-led and proportionate. Trustees can use self-assessment to select priorities, assign owners and revisit progress, building a routine of reflection rather than treating good practice as a one-off project.